| Event ID | Date | Time | End | Day | Location | Visitor | V Score | Home | H Score | Status |
| 870003 | 9/12/2023 | 6:45 PM | 8:00 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #2 | Hitmen | 4 | South Sliders | 17 | Completed |
| 870018 | 9/12/2023 | 8:00 PM | 9:15 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #2 | South Sliders | 23 | Hitmen | 4 | Completed |
| 870005 | 9/19/2023 | 6:45 PM | 8:00 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #1 | Hitmen | 19 | Dad Bodgodz | 26 | Completed |
| 870020 | 9/19/2023 | 8:00 PM | 9:15 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #1 | Dad Bodgodz | 11 | Hitmen | 10 | Completed |
| 870011 | 10/3/2023 | 6:45 PM | 8:00 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #1 | Bashers | 18 | Hitmen | 21 | Completed |
| 870026 | 10/3/2023 | 8:00 PM | 9:15 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #1 | Hitmen | 7 | Bashers | 18 | Completed |
| 870015 | 10/10/2023 | 6:45 PM | 8:00 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #2 | Hitmen | 0 | Sure Hit Home Improvement | 7 | Completed |
| 870030 | 10/10/2023 | 8:00 PM | 9:15 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #2 | Sure Hit Home Improvement | 7 | Hitmen | 0 | Completed |
| 870007 | 10/17/2023 | 6:45 PM | 8:00 PM | Tue | Raritan Bay Park / Softball Field #2 | Roosevelt Reds | 0 | Hitmen | 7 | Completed |
| 870022 | 10/17/2023 | 8:00 PM | 9:15 PM | Tue | Raritan Bay Park / Softball Field #2 | Hitmen | 7 | Roosevelt Reds | 0 | Completed |
| 870031 | 10/24/2023 | 6:45 PM | 8:00 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #1 | Hitmen | 14 | Dad Bodgodz | 12 | Completed |
| 870032 | 10/24/2023 | 8:00 PM | 9:15 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #1 | Dad Bodgodz | 32 | Hitmen | 14 | Completed |
| 870033 | 10/24/2023 | 9:15 PM | 10:30 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #1 | Hitmen | 23 | Dad Bodgodz | 10 | Completed |
| 870036 | 10/31/2023 | 6:45 PM | 8:00 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #1 | Hitmen | 7 | Sure Hit Home Improvement | 21 | Completed |
| 870037 | 10/31/2023 | 8:00 PM | 9:15 PM | Tue | William Warren Park / Softball Field #1 | Sure Hit Home Improvement | 14 | Hitmen | 1 | Completed |